How do we buy wine? Thats the question I’ve been trying to answer for years, and it still comes down to price — even more than quality
The wine business sells a lot of wine, but there are very few good numbers explaining why we buy what we buy. Is it price? Is it taste? Is it ratings? Is it the label? Is it magic?
Hence my attempts over the years to put a human face on this question: What influences us to buy the wine that we buy? The most important, as near as I can tell from talking to consumers for more than a decade, is price. The second? That the wine they’re buying doesn’t taste like wine – that is, it doesn’t taste like they expect it to taste, bitter and acidic. Instead, and my colleagues need to control their tempers here, they like wine that has what the call a smooth taste.
I saw this again in early May waiting in line at my neighborhood Aldi, where the customer in front of me – an older white man, and wealthy by the size of his SUV in the parking lot – was buying a bottle of Winking Owl merlot. That’s a $3 bottle that can best be described as inoffensive, but is neither bitter nor acidic.
The Wine Curmudgeon, being the son and grandson of retailers, asked the man what he liked about the Winking Owl, and mentioned that he might like Aldi’s Vina Fuerte even more.
His response? “How much does your wine cost?” About $5, I said. “I’ll think about it,” he said. “This is really good wine for the money,” pointing to the Winking Owl, “and everyone likes it – even people who don’t like wine, and even people I didn’t think would like it.”
So we can argue about premiumizaton all we want, parse the numbers about what’s hot and what’s not, and wax annoyingly about the latest cult wine that none of us can afford to buy. But in the store, none of that matters. It’s price and it’s taste. The rest is just there to confuse us.
More about how we buy wine
• Once more, how consumers buy wine
• How people really buy wine
• Another study agrees: We buy wine on price










