Tag Archives: pinot noir

Angeline Winery: Value, quality, and honest wine

angeline wineryFour wines worth drinking, for value and cost, from California’s Angeline and Martin Ray wineries

Maybe it’s because winemaker Bill Batchelor was an anthropology major in college. Maybe it’s because Angeline Winery and its sister label, the high-end Martin Ray, are not corporate in any way, shape, or form. Or maybe it’s because someone in California understands quality is not about what the hipsters are drinking, but about making honest wine.

Regardless, my visit last month with Batchelor during his trip to Dallas was almost too much fun. Imagine a winemaker who barely mentioned scores once during our chat, and you’ll get the idea.

“One of the things we keep in mind is that we don’t want to chase trends,” says Batchelor. “We want our wines to represent the place where they came from.”

All of the eight wines I tasted demonstrated that approach, and even the most expensive offered value in addition to quality and terroir. Among my favorites:

• Angeline Reserve Pinot Noir 2016 ($16, sample, 13.9%): I’ve been bellyaching for years about how few pinot noirs that cost less than $25 taste like pinot noir, but this spring has seen four or five to reverse the trend. This is classic California pinot noir – not as earthy as Burgundy or as zesty as Oregon, but with fresh raspberry fruit balanced by bright acidity and just a hint of oak at the back. Highly recommended.

• Angeline Reserve Sauvignon Blanc 2016 ($13, sample, 13.8%): This white has more tropical and stone fruit flavors than the typical California sauvignon blanc, but that just makes it more interesting. And it, too, is balanced, so that that it remains fresh despite the softer fruit flavors.

• Angeline Rose of Pinot Noir 2016 ($13, sample, 12.5%): This rose does the always reliable Charles & Charles one step better – some floral aromas (orange blossom?), plus candied strawberry fruit and a crisp citrus finish. Highly recommended.

• Martin Ray Synthesis Cabernet Sauvignon 2014 ($50, sample, 14.8%): This is a Napa Valley cabernet (with a smattering of cabernet franc and petit verdot) that tastes like wine and not a chemistry experiment designed to get the highest score possible. Look for blueberry and plum fruit, an herbal something or other, and just the right amount of oak to support everything that is going on. Also impressive: the wine handles the high alcohol nicely, and it doesn’t get in the way. Ready to drink now, and should age for at least two or three more years.

Mini-reviews 95: Geyser Peak, Triton Tridente, Cloudline, Anne Amie

geyser peakReviews of wines that don’t need their own post, but are worth noting for one reason or another. Look for it on the fourth Friday of each month.

• Geyser Peak Sauvignon Blanc 2015 ($12, sample, 13%): I’m sure the current owners of Geyser Peak, once a great cheap sauvignon blanc, had their reasons for blending this vintage with riesling. The reason, though, escapes me, since it adds an almost syrupy consistency and sweetness to a wine that is supposed to be crisp and fresh. Plus, $12?

• Bodegas Tritón Tridente 2013 ($16, sample, 15.5%): This Spanish tempranillo sat in the wine closet for more than a year, and the age made all the difference in the world. Much better than I expected – rich and lush with cherry fruit but not hot despite the high alcohol.

• Cloudline Pinot Noir 2015 ($16, sample, 13.5%): This Oregon red from the well-known Domaine Drouhin is not for all tastes, made in an almost old-fashioned French style. That means tart berry fruit and very simple in style.

• Anne Amie Cuvee A Amrita 2015 ($15, sample, 12.6%): This Oregon white blend, from one of my favorite producers, is a cross between a frizzante riesling and a sweeter, more Prosecco style sparkling. It is well made, as all Anne Amie wines are, with citrus and white fruit, but could use more acidity to balance the sweetness.

 

 

Wine of the week: Castle Rock Pinot Noir Willamette Valley 2015

Castle Rock Pinot NoirThe Castle Rock Pinot Noir is affordable, well-made, enjoyable and even tastes like pinot noir

After years of complaining that it was almost impossible to find affordable pinot noir that tasted like pinot noir. we’ve already had two as wines of the week this year. The second, the Castle Rock pinot noir, may be the more interesting.

That’s because the Castle Rock pinot noir ($12, sample, 13.5%) is a negociant-style wine, where the people making it don’t necessarily own any grapes or winemaking facilities. It’s a common practice in France, but much less common in the U.S. In the case of the Castle Rock pinot noir, it works well.

Look for the telltale red and black berry fruit in this red wine from Oregon, a little freshness, a competent finish with a touch of length, and what tastes like nicely done fake oak. Also, there are surprisingly professional tannins that hide in the background and don’t get in the way of the wine; in fact, they even sort of complement it. In much cheap pinot noir, the tannins are either missing completely or are so harsh that they overpower the wine.

Is this classic Oregon pinot noir? No, but it’s not supposed to be. It’s supposed to be affordable pinot noir that tastes like pinot noir, which is as rare as it is welcome. Enjoy this on any weeknight, and be glad you didn’t pay $20 for a pinot that you didn’t like nearly as much.

 

Expensive wine 96: Eyrie Vineyards Original Vines Pinot Noir 2013

Eyrie Vineyards Original Vines pinot noirars of Oregon winemaking traditionThe Eyrie Vineyards Original Vines pinot noir speaks to more than 40 years of Oregon winemaking tradition

Once, wine was about history and tradition, and not descriptors. The story of the wine was what mattered, and not whether it was redolent of graphite and cigar box aromas. It’s the latter that makes the Eyrie Vineyards Original Vines Pinot Noir so special.

The Eyrie Original Vines pinot noir ($80, sample, 13%) is made with grapes from the vines that the late David Lett planted more than 40 years ago when he came to Oregon to grow pinot noir. Lett, who pioneered the grape in Oregon, was considered crazy for doing so – why would anyone leave California for the wilderness of the Pacific Northwest to make wine with a grape that only the French did well?

This wine answers that question. It speaks to Lett’s vision and passion – an elegant and graceful effort that reminds us that wine can be about terroir and the people who make it, and not focus groups, sales charts, and price points. It also shows that winemaker Jason Lett has taken his father’s vision and updated it to the 21st century

Look for elegance and grace, a wine that can hold its own with any of the world’s best. It has Oregon’s telltale brambly cherry fruit, but so much more – layers and layers of complexity, black pepper interspersed with the fruit, tannins that hang around just long enough but not too long, a memory of oak that is just enough to do the job, and who knows what else going on. It will age well for the next several years at least, and maybe even longer.

Highly recommended, the kind of wine to buy for someone who loves wine and will appreciate the effort and history that went into it.

Wine of the week: Wine by Joe Pinot Noir 2014

 Wine by Joe Pinot NoirThe Wine by Joe Pinot Noir shows it’s possible to make great pinot that is also affordable

Joe Dobbes is an Oregon winemaking legend, which makes this wine all that more amazing. When do winemaking legends make wine that most of us can afford?

In fact, the Wine by Joe Pinot Noir ($16, sample, 13.5%) is about as cheap as real pinot noir gets, and it’s a better quality pinot than many that cost twice as much. But Dobbes’ decades of experience with pinot noir has given him both the experience and the mindset to make this kind of wine. Dobbes worked in the French region of Burgundy, the heartbeat of pinot, and helped put Oregon pinot on the map when he was the winemaker at Willamette Valley Vineyards.

The Wine by Joe pinot noir is not just varietally correct, but tastes like Oregon pinot noir. This matters in an age when the goal seems to be to turn pinot into a red blend, tarting it up with sweet fruit and even residual sugar. Instead, the wine has the spicy, brambly quality that an Oregon pinot noir should have, along with bright cherry fruit; those essential, barely noticeable pinot tannins; and a balance that made me wish I had a bottle to taste, and not just a few sips at a trade event.

Highly recommended, and more than worth the extra cost. Serve this with roast chicken or lamb, and be glad Dobbes understands quality is not something reserved for expensive wine.

Barefoot wine review 2016

Barefoot wine review 2016The Barefoot wine review 2016: an interesting pinot grigio and a pinot noir that isn’t very pinot noir-ish.

The Barefoot wine review 2016 goes a long way toward explaining why the market for wine that costs less than $10 has been eroding for a couple of years — save for Barefoot. These wines are professional and technically competent, but more importantly are made for specific groups who know what they like and will buy what they like.

The pinot grigio ($10, purchased, 12.5%) is more like pinot gris, with sort of soft lemon fruit and more acidity than I expected. This is not a tonic water pinot grigio like similarly priced Italian wines; instead, the Barefoot straddles the line between the two styles. It’s also sweet – not moscato or white zinfandel sweet, but with a touch of residual sugar that you’ll notice on the back of your tongue. There is lots of winemaking going on here, but the result is drinkable, especially if well chilled and of you don’t mind the sweetness. The pinot grigio is American appellation and non-vintage.

It’s not so much that the pinot noir ($10, purchased, 13.5%) doesn’t taste like pinot noir. You can say that about a lot of pinots that cost less than $25 and are made more like cheap red blends. Rather, my sense is that the goal was to make a wine that tastes like the kind of wine that people who don’t drink much wine think red wine should taste like. Yes, a complicated sentence, but it means that the pinot noir is a little rough and not smooth in the way many wine drinkers describe wine. Plus, the tannins are surprisingly noticeable and not well integrated, something that almost never happens with a Barefoot wine. The pinot noir is American appellation and non-vintage.

Finally, a word about the price of the wine, which was almost 50 percent higher than it should have been – $10 instead of $7. I bought both bottles at the same supermarket where I buy Barefoot every year for the review, and that was the price. Call it premiumization or grocery store pricing or whatever, but it means the wines are that much less of a value given the higher price.

More about Barefoot wine:
• Barefoot wine review 2015
• Barefoot wine review 2014
• Barefoot: Almost the best-selling wine in the U.S.

Expensive wine 86: Louis Latour Corton Grand Cru 2004

Latour Corton Grand CruIt has always been difficult to understand the post-modern French haste to sell their wine birthright to anyone who will pony up too much money for a mediocre product. Why make overpriced plonk to get a high score when you can do it the right way and make something that has amazed the world for centuries?

Case in point is the Latour Corton Grand Cru ($365, sample, 14%), which is everything French wine has been and should be. This is red Burgundy, pinot noir from the Corton section in Burgundy, and any discussion of Corton involves hundreds of years of history and which particular spot on a hill in Corton the grapes came from. If that’s the starting point, why do you need anything else?

I tasted this wine at the Sunday night dinner for Critics Challenge judges, attended by the handful of us who have to stay an extra night. The judges bring wine (I brought some Texas, of course, which was well received), and competition organizer Robert Whitley adds some from his cellar. This came from Robert, and it was the kind of wine that makes you pause after a sip to wonder how it’s possible to make that kind of wine.

The Latour Corton Grand Cru was earthy and dark, but because 2004 was a warm vintage, it also had more red fruit than I expected. Yet those descriptors are almost useless, because this wine won’t be ready to drink for at least five or six years, and probably longer. That means it’s certainly delicious now, but hasn’t aged long enough to bring the whole into focus, and is too young for the various components to have come together. The best analogy I can think of? Marinating a piece of beef or chicken, where the ultimate goal is not to taste the marinade, but to make the beef or chicken taste better.

Highly recommended, and don’t worry too much about the price. That has been skewed by demand in Asia, where a bottle costs more than five times what it costs in Europe. I found this wine for €44 France, about US$60. Not cheap, but more than fair considering what you get.