Virginia Governor’s Cup 2010
? What is it? The largest competition in Virginia, featuring wines from throughout the state. We judged more than 200 red wines.
? When and where: Jan. 23, 2010, Loudoun County, Va.
? Biggest surprise: That I liked the wines better than the Virginia-based judges. Seriously. I think this is a function of familiarity breeding contempt, or at least higher expectations.
? What’s different: We only did red; the white wine judging will take place in October. This is very unusual, and was a nice touch, cutting the number of wines to judge — and our tasting fatigue — in half. Also, the results weren’t released at the end of the day, which is also unusual. I’ll update this when the results are announced.
? Who I judged with: Philip Prifold, who teaches wine classes for the Washington, D.C., Art Institute culinary program and the International Sommelier Guild; wine broker Ellen Shull, who was judging her first competition and did quite well; retailer Lucinda Smith; and Pennsylvania grape grower Stewart Nelson. Nelson, incidentally, is a retired concert violinist. Don’t get to judge with too many of those.
? Compensation: The organizers paid my airfare, two hotel nights, and half of a rental car. (I stayed in Virginia to do some other wine business, which accounts for the other half of the rental car.)
? Overall: Most of the wines were more than competent, and I was quite impressed with the quality. The best wines, in a blind tasting with wines from other parts of the world, would more than hold their own. Virginia is developing a first-class wine industry, with distinctive terroir.








