Tag Archives: sommelier scandal

Winebits 725: Franzia holiday outfits, sommelier scandal, Big Wine

franzia christmas
$50, and the sweater is yours — and it lights up!

This week’s wine news: More Franzia holiday outfits, plus six sommeliers could be be expelled and Big Wine is shopping a property

• Bring on the Franzia outfits – again: The WC can’t help himself – the idea of adults dressing up like wine boxes appeals to something in me that I can’t explain. This time, it’s a Franzia Christmas sweater that lights up (yes, the one in the picture). The sweater, in case anyone is interested, costs $50. The other thing I like about these Franzia promotions? The marketers call people who drink the wine and buy this stuff “Franz” (like friends – get it?) That’s so horribly awful that I can only shake my head in admiration. Wish I could get paid for writing puns like that. The bravest among you can check out anther Franzia costume promotions here.

• Sommelier scandal: The Court of Master Sommeliers has moved to revoke the certifications of six members who were accused of sexual misconduct about a year ago, including one of the group’s co-founders. Hearings will be held within 30 days to decide whether to revoke the memberships. They include Fred Dame, one of its co-founders; Robert Bath, a professor of wine at St. Helena’s Culinary Institute of America; Matt Stamp of Compline Restaurant and Wine Shop in Napa; Fred Dexheimer; Drew Hendricks; and Joseph Linder. The sex scandal is the second major scandal facing the group; three years ago, it had to cancel the results of an exam after one of the members gave part of the test to someone taking it.

• Stag’s Leap sale? Sycamore Partners, the hedge fund that bought Ste. Michelle Wine Estates, as already looking to break up the company. Which, of course, is what hedge funds do. It may be asking as much as $1 billion for Stag’s Leap, a Napa winery that isn’t this producer. Bloomberg reports that “Stag’s Leap is expected to attract interest from high-net worth family offices and other private equity firms, the people said. No final decision has been made and Sycamore could elect to keep the business.” Welcome to the 21st century, wine business.

Winebits 709: Sommelier arson, wine delivery, hat etiquette

Wine Curmudgeon
“OK — tell me again how to avoid hat hair.”

This week’s wine news: Sommelier arrested for arson, plus wine delivery’s future and hat etiquette — because hats matter in cheap wine

• Arson charges: Caleb Ganzer, a former Food & Wine magazine sommelier of the year and a partner in a well-regarded Manhattan wine bar, is facing arson charges. The New York Times reports that New York City police arrested Ganzer last week and charged him with two felony counts of arson and several other crimes in connection with three fires, including two at outdoor dining sheds in Manhattan. There was no indication of motive.

• Bring on delivery: Wine retailers continue to see delivery — jump-started by the pandemic — as key to success in whatever becomes the new normal, says Market Watch magazine. The “emergence of on-demand delivery has resulted in added sales, while consumers have quickly become enamored by the convenience and reduced-friction transactions the services offer.” Delivery has always been something small retailers had mixed emotions about, since it usually offered as much aggravation as it did profit. But better websites, third-party delivery services like Drizly, and relaxed state laws have reduced the former and offered more of the latter.

• Hat hair: The WC doesn’t want to hear this isn’t a wine item — how can I spread the gospel of cheap wine without knowing hat etiquette? And, of course, how to fix hat hair? Fortunately, The New York Times’ Ask Vanessa column solves all. I knew most of the etiquette; it’s the hat hair stuff that was a revelation: Use “dry shampoo, also known as hair powder.” Who knew, given the long, sordid history of hair powder? Her advice? Excuse yourself to powder your hair, sprinkle hair powder into your hands and scrunch. Who knows? Maybe I can get an endorsement deal.

Winebits 707: On-line wine, sommeliers, Beaujolais Nouveau

on-line wine
Is wine education a key part of the success of on-line wine sales?

This week’s wine news: Ray Isle dissects the on-line wine trend, plus scandal-rocked sommeliers’ group hires an executive director, and an odd lament for Beaujolais Nouveau

• On-line wine to the rescue? Food & Wine’s Ray Isle explains how and why buying wine on-line wine made inroads during the pandemic: “It’s clear we’re on the cusp of an entirely new wine-buying landscape. But what will that mean?” He notes that non-winery wine clubs – and no, not the 12 wines for a $1 that we’ve discussed here – could be more important than ever. That’s because they offer wine education as well; hence, consumers can buy and learn about wine regions, styles of wine, natural wine, and the like, and all from home.

• New executive director: The predominantly male Court of Master Sommeliers, Americas, rocked by a series of sexual scandals last year, has hired an executive director. Julie Cohen Theobald, armed with a University of Chicago MBA and a success as a high-level marketing executive at Procter & Gamble, seems to have what’s needed to reform the Court – if its members are serious about reform. But as the North Bay Business Journal noted, Theobald’s appointment did not mention the sex scandal or the earlier cheating mess, and included some wonderful PR-speak: “the Court of Master Sommeliers, Americas is committed to drive both internal and external change by engaging with its members, stakeholders, and larger community.” Engaging stakeholders, indeed.

• Beaujolais Nouveau: Beaujolais Nouveau, once a November tradition for U.S. wine drinkers, has long been out of favor. This story, from one of the Winestream Media, is the usual sort of marketing-inspired foolishness that passes for wine journalism. The wine’s sales declined, “a victim of its own success in America.” I have no idea what that means, and it obscures a larger issue: Wine quality got worse and worse, so that the wines eventually smelled of overripe bananas and didn’t taste much better. Who would want to buy that?

Photo: Mikel Parera on Unsplash

The sommelier cheating scandal just won’t go away

• Podcast with Newsy journalist Mark Greenblatt: People are afraid to talk about what happened

Newsy website reports that sommelier cheating scandal may be part of more extensive problems at Court of Master Sommeliers

Remember last year’s sommelier cheating scandal, which grabbed the cyber-headlines and then mysteriously disappeared? The Newsy website reports that the scandal may be part of larger problems at the organization that oversees the master sommelier program.

“[S]everal current master sommeliers are going public for the first time by speaking to Newsy,” reports the website. “They have grown concerned about more ‘systemic’ problems plaguing the Court of Master Sommeliers, the nonprofit governing body that administers the group’s exams.”

The report – you can watch it in the video at the top of the post or read the transcript – outlines what appears to be an attempt to stonewall outsiders from finding out exactly what happened.  All we know is that someone gave the list of wines for the blind tasting portion of the test to at least one candidate, the results were then invalidated, and the sommelier group said all else was fine.

Since then, the court has revised its code of ethics to include a provision that would punish master sommeliers who criticized the organization: Newsy reports that the new code “warned of ‘disciplinary action’ for ‘any action or utterance’ by a master sommelier that ‘could be construed as detrimental’ to the Court’s good name.’ ”

Says one master sommelier in the report: “I took that as, you know, ‘Be quiet. Don’t question our authority or we’ll kick you out. There are some fundamental things that are wrong.”

None of this is surprising. I made a few phone calls in the aftermath of the scandal, and couldn’t even get anyone to talk off the record. They didn’t want to talk at all; as one well-known master sommelier told me, “I advised them to go public, and they ignored me. It’s their problem now.”

The reason for the group’s behavior is not surprising: money and power. As I wrote last year, “Sommelier-ing has become an industry in and of itself – movies, even. Sommeliers are the current rock stars of the wine business, perhaps even more quoted and revered than the celebrity winemakers who used to dominate the discussion.”

But the minute it looks like those MS initials are worthless, all of that collapses. So the court, according to the Newsy report, has done all it can to make sure no one finds out exactly what happened. And, if anyone does find out, to punish them for telling the rest of us.

It’s also not surprising that a Mainstream Media outlet had to pursue the story. There’s little incentive for the Winestream Media to follow up on the scandal. It has almost as much invested in turning sommeliers into rock stars as the sommeliers do. Who do you think put all these people on a pedestal in the first place?

Winebits 593: Sommelier scandal, wine scores, sparkling wine glasses

This week’s wine news: Ron Washam puts the sommelier scandal in focus, plus more on why wine scores don’t work and yet another examination of sparkling wine glasses

• “Ethics and truth are Roundup for the wine business:” Ron Washam, writing on Tim Atkin’s website, offers some much needed perspective on last fall’s sommelier scandal, in which a then-sommelier apparently gave a list of the wines to be used for the blind tasting portion of the master sommelier exam to one of the candidates. “The wine world moves on,” he writes, “unconcerned with ethics and truth, as well it should. Ethics and truth are Roundup for the wine business. You don’t want to use them liberally, or at all, they pretty much destroy the ecosystem.” As Washam notes, the Court of Master Sommeliers has brushed the scandal under the rug, and sommeliers remain wine royalty. Is it any wonder that I worry about the future of the wine business?

• No more scores: Ian Cauble, writing in the Robb Report, hits scores firmly up the side of the head: “A high score doesn’t always mean the wine is excellent. …” he says, and then explains why. In this, his is one more voice trying to free us from the tyranny of 92 points. “Don’t assume the score tacked onto a shelf is Holy Writ,” he writes. “Drink and acquire what you like. Above all, remember that wine is about the land, the people who make it, and the friends with whom you enjoy it. A single score never defines the full story.” I could not have said that better myself, and I have been trying for almost 20 years.

• Put it in the glass: Christopher Walkey, writing for Glass of Bubbly, dissects sparkling wine glasses in all their shapes and sizes. In fact, there’s even a photo of seven kinds of glasses – just looking at it made my head hurt. The reason for the article is the past several years worth of carping about which glass best serves sparkling wine and Champagne. Which, to Ron Washam’s point, says a lot about what the wine business considers to be important.

Photo: “Sommelier” by Antonio Calero Garcia is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0 

Winebits 568: Sommelier scandal, Yellow Tail ad, porn

sommelier scandalThis week’s wine news: A conspiracy theory takes shape around the sommelier scandal, plus we’re stuck with another Yellow Tail Super Bowl ad and I’ve been offered a chance to run adult content on the blog

• Conspiracy theory? Liza Zimmerman, writing for Forbes, quotes one observer as wondering if a distributor conspiracy was behind last month’s sommelier cheating scandal. He doubted if “this was really the first time such a thing has occurred during the exam. He shared his suspicions that the wholesale tier’s influence on the Court is growing and noted that wholesalers who mentor favorite sommeliers think that they may be able to curry favor with them later on.” That’s an interesting theory, that sommeliers who work for distributors were helping candidates cheat so the cheaters would be beholden to distributors. But even those of us who think distributors are much of what’s wrong with the business aren’t sure that they’re quite that bad.

• Oh, the horror: Yellow Tail, not content with its sad and much disliked Super Bowl TV ad, is going to do it again in 2019. The Australian wine company, reports Shanken News Daily, has issued a call for wine drinkers to send their Yellow Tail videos to the company to be used in the 2019 ad. I shudder at the possibilities, though the one good thing is that we probably won’t have to suffer through the Roo again.

• Adult content: A marketing company in Gibraltar wants to “to buy a guest post on your website for our adult website guide. Rest assured, we can use both explicit and non-explicit keywords, which ever you prefer.” I won’t link to the company, whose clients include a company called YouPorn as well as Sony Music and Netflix. Obviously, I told them no, but I’ve been wondering ever since what they saw in my metrics to make the offer. What’s the relationship between wine drinkers and porn?