Tag Archives: Pinotgate

Winebits 200: Pinotgate, wine apps, mommy drinking

? Judge upholds sentences: Decanter, the British wine magazine, may not care all that much about most of the U.S. wine business, but it does love to follow the Gallo pinot noir scandal. Or, as the magazine calls it, "the notorious Red Bicyclette fake Pinot Noir case." The entire story is worth reading, and not because a French appeals court upheld the sentences of those convicted of selling syrah and merlot to Gallo and pretending it was pinot. Read the story for  Decanter's wonderfully English tabloid slant to the case, in which it tars everyone involved with the brush of scandal. One other note: No one, even at Gallo, is quite sure which bottles of pinot had the syrah or merlot in it instead of pinot. So if you see a bottle of 2008 Red Bicyclette pinot noir on a store shelf (and there may still be some), you could be buying a piece of history.

? The failure of wine apps: Paul Mabray, one of the smartest people in the modern wine marketing business, takes a look at wine apps for smart phones and pronounces them dead on arrival. "We want to believe differently but the reality is the the bells are ringing for the current apps ? get better than 'most promising' or R.I.P." Which makes perfect sense. You hear about all sorts of apps, but when's the last time you've heard about a wine app? Mabray lists nine reasons why the apps don't make a difference; my favorite is the last one: "Reference apps are great but all of their content be already be found through a major search engine or just by asking your friends/followers/fans on a social network." Yes, let's duplicate free content, charge people for it, and then wonder why we're not making milliions.

? When should mommys drink wine? This is more the province of my pal Tom Johnson at Louisville Juice, who follows mommy wine with a keen eye and a sharp keyboard, but the item is too interesting to pass up. In the wake of the Missouri mother whose child disappeared while mom was drinking too much wine, the TODAY Moms blog asks: "Is drinking on the mommy job a no-no?" Writes the blog: "We ?ve all had those days when we think, to use the old, un-PC expression, 'My kids are driving me to drink.' And while grown-up time is crucial for our sanity, is it anything goes after dark?" The Wine Curmudgeon, who does not pretend to be any sort of expert when it comes to raising children, wonders why the question needs to be asked. Passing out drunk, children or no, is rarely a good idea.

Winebits 151: Champagne, restaurant wine, Pinotgate

? Champagne sales slump: I suppose this isn't news to any of us who have been paying attention, but someone did feel the need to write a report. Champagne sales — that is, sparkling wine made in the Champagne region of France — fared worse during the recession than the rest of the sparkling wine business. Champagne sales fell by 3.6 percent in 2009, which is an amazing figure, and more than twice as much as non-Champagne sales fell. Until, of course, one realizes that it's almost impossible to buy a bottle of Champagne for less than $20, while there are dozens of quality options that aren't Champagne, such as Spanish cava, Italian bubblies, and U.S. brands like Domaine Ste. Michelle for much less than $20.

? The quality of restaurant wine: Tom Johnson at Louisville Juice picked up this nugget (and how does he always find these things?). A CNN blogger who doesn't drink wine decided to sample a pinot grigio from the wine list at a national Italian chain. The result was predictable. "It tasted like rubbing alcohol turned bad." Which, as regular visitors here know, is one of the Wine Curmudgeon's common complaints about poorly made Italian pinot grigio. Reporting this item gives me the chance to do three of my favorite things — rail against the quality of restaurant wine lists; lament that too many people are introduced to wine through poor quality restaurant wine lists; and note something that puts a TV journalist in a less than complimentary light (once a newspaperman, always a newspaperman).

? Gallo pinot fraud: Gina Gallo, the heir to the empire, says the 2009 Pinotgate scandal, in which E&J Gallo's Red Bicyclette label sold some 1.5 million cases of fake pinot noir from the Languedoc in southern France, was a disaster. "As a company we want to be squeaky clean, and we are scrupulous in declaring alcohol levels and other matters, so of course it was an embarrassment to us," she told Decanter magazine. This is, as far as I can tell, the first time an important Gallo official has commented on the scandal, which included criminal prosecutions and convictions in France.