Tag Archives: direct sales

Is New York liquor ruling a setback for Amazon?

Amazon Wine, the Internet retailer's end-run around the three-tier system, may be in trouble. The New York State Liquor Authority, reports Wine Industry Insight, has fined a New York retailer for $50,000 for ?third-party liquor sales. ?

Said the authority in its ruling: ?Arguably, since these third party companies are not licensed to sell alcohol, they are violating the three tier system. Additionally, by participating in this arrangement, retailers could be construed as availing their license and sharing their profits with these companies, all of which weaken the system and do not conform to the rules and regulations that govern sales of alcohol. ?

The ruling was not directed at Amazon, and the case is not exactly the same ? the retailer was fined for selling wine on the Internet in conjunction with a distributor. Amazon doesn ?t ?sell wine, ? but allows consumers to use its marketplace to buy wine from retailers and wineries, All Amazon says it does is facilitate the sale, for which it takes a cut from the retailers and wineries.

Still, that sounds a lot like a third-party retailer, and Amazon doesn't help matters by calling itself a wine store on the site. And, as I reported last fall when the program was announced, there was no guarantee it wouldn ?t run afoul of ?newly aggressive state regulators, who might be inclined to sue Amazon just because. ?

Amazon Wine launched in 2012 even though it wasn ?t available in New York, the most important wine market in the country. This ruling seems to indicate it may be a long while before the marketplace gets there. In addition, though the decision has no meaning outside of New York, liquor cops across the country will undoubtedly be parsing it for ways to use in in their jurisdictions.

Winebits 269: Champagne, wine in grocery stores, Amazon

? More bad news for  bubbly: Just when you thought it couldn ?t get worse for Champagne, it did. Sales fell 4.4 percent the 12 months through December, according to the Comit Interprofessionnel du Vin de Champagne trade group. And Champagne shipments to the U.S. were down 25 percent in the first six months of last year, continuing that trend. And to think ? it wasn ?t all that long ago that the Champagne business was considering expanding the size of the Champagne region so they would have more land to get grapes from.

? Never underestimate three-tier: Abut a year ago, a federal judge ruled that a Kentucky law that banned grocery store wine sales was unconstitutional. So what ?s advancing through the Kentucky legislature? A more constitutional version of the ban, reports wkyufu,org. Said the bill ?s sponsor: ?So we would have liquor in convenience stores, dollar stores, wherever they could get a liquor license. And that's something that nobody wanted. ? Nobody, of course, not being the state ?s wine drinkers, who don ?t have the campaign cash to pay legislators to write bills for them. but the state ?s retailers who want to keep grocers out.

? Amazon adds two states: And they ?re not New York and Pennsylvania, which speaks volumes about how difficult it is to sell wine directly to the consumer in the U.S. If you live in Colorado or South Carolina, you can now use the Amazon service, which includes 15 states and the District of Columbia. Amazon usually doesn ?t break out many sales figures, but we should be coming up the first quarter of its wine retail operation. The numbers would be fascinating.